Bold fans, buckle up because this fall may deliver one of the most shocking twists in years. Rumors suggest Hope Logan could soon be facing a pregnancy bombshell, and the ripple effects could tear through Los Angeles like an earthquake. But the real kicker? If she is pregnant, there’s no guarantee whether Liam Spencer or Carter Walton is the father. That’s right—this could ignite a paternity mystery so explosive it reshapes relationships, divides families, and leaves broken hearts scattered everywhere.

So, what would it mean if Hope really is staring at a positive test? Let’s dive in.

Carter’s Quiet Collapse

Carter Walton has been nothing if not steady. Loyal, dependable, and endlessly patient, he’s been the rock Hope turned to after her marriage to Liam unraveled. For months, he’s offered her something she thought she wanted—security, peace, and a love free from chaos. Their engagement looked perfect on paper. Yet beneath the surface, cracks have been spreading, and now they’re impossible to ignore.

Spoilers hint that Carter will soon voice the words he’s been holding back: “Go to your family, Hope.” Not out of anger, but out of brutal honesty. He sees what Hope has been trying to deny—her heart is still tied to Liam, and no amount of stability can rewrite that truth. This quiet unraveling marks the end of their engagement before it truly begins.

For Carter, it’s another devastating chapter. Time after time, he’s given everything only to be left behind. But this time cuts deeper, because Hope does care for him. She simply doesn’t love him enough. And yet, the cruel irony could still lie ahead. If Hope is pregnant, Carter may believe he finally has what he’s longed for his entire life—a family of his own. But what happens if that baby turns out to be Liam’s? Would fatherhood finally redeem Carter, or crush him in a heartbreak he might never recover from?

Liam’s Relentless Pursuit

While Carter prepares to let go, Liam is doubling down. Determined to win Hope back, he’s been tugging at every emotional string. The father-daughter dance with Beth wasn’t just a touching moment; it was a calculated reminder that Liam and Hope aren’t just a couple—they’re a family.

For Liam, this feels like destiny. He’s made it clear that their story isn’t finished, that they’re meant to be together. And for Hope, these memories hit hard. She can’t ignore the warmth of seeing Liam with Beth, nor can she deny that the family picture she longs for is one Carter simply doesn’t fit.

But here’s where things get volatile. Hope hasn’t been living like a saint. She’s shared months of passion with Carter, and now rumors say she’s been pulled back into Liam’s arms as well. The timing couldn’t be more dramatic—or more dangerous.

The Pregnancy Bombshell

Imagine the fallout if Hope discovers she’s pregnant after overlapping relationships with two men. The father could be either Carter or Liam, and her entire future could hinge on a single DNA test. Would Liam still pursue her if the child is Carter’s? Would Carter, who has just stepped aside, reclaim his place as a father even without the engagement? This isn’t just a love triangle anymore—it’s a ticking time bomb of loyalty, legacy, and longing.

And in true soap fashion, the rules are clear: sleep with two men in the same timeframe, and a pregnancy twist is almost guaranteed. If Hope is holding that test soon, the show is setting up its biggest paternity mystery in years.